
Illustration by ThaZumi
I read this post by Eric Karjaluoto with an interview with Blair Enns of winwithoutpitching.com. In reference to design firms screwing things up with their sales strategies, he mentions the following:
The only real way for a firm to shift the power (from client to firm) is to eliminate as many substitutes to hiring their firm as possible. They do this by building a deep expertise. The easiest way to build deep expertise is to narrow the focus of the firm. But this is where the conflict starts. Creative people, by their very nature, have broad interests and tend to resist focus.
The typical designer will want to offer everything to everyone because of their “limitless creativity,” fear of missing opportunities or simply because of the fact that everyone else is doing it—including all the big players in the industry.
What’s misunderstood is that these big players came during a time when there never was an industry. They arrived in a vacuum (or a minimally competitive market) which is the reason they’re able to play the field like they’re doing now. Newer ones don’t have that luxury.
Young and new designers have to learn to focus. When they focus, they establish themselves as the gurus in that field. They go to places where they become unreachable. Barriers to entry begin to shoot up and competition won’t be able to casually copy like they do.
Suddenly, there is no (direct) competition because the bar in the playing field has been raised. They’re no longer competing in the design rat race.
From a consumer product standpoint, look at companies like Wacom, the leader of pen tablets. Microsoft, Genius, Logitech and others have the capability to produce tablets and compete in the field; but people still buy from them because of their expertise in making pen tablets. Because of their focus on their few products, they are able to perfect it and make it the best that the industry can offer. They’re irreplaceable and unstoppable.
From an artist’s standpoint, check out Pablo Picasso. Although he was creative enough to be able to do so many forms of painting and illustrating, he persistently mastered his craft in Cubism, which eventually made him a legend.
As designers, what do we really want to focus on? Brands Identity? Layouts? Environments? Publications? Illustration? Motion Graphics? Packaging? Print and Production Finishing? Web Design? Typography & Lettering? Design Thinking?
Pick or die.
Here are some good examples of design firms who focus:
Matchstic—Brand Identity house
Motionographer—Motion Graphics Specialist
Hoefler & Frere Jones—Typography Masters
On the other side, I don’t have to enumerate bad examples because there are just too much to list down. Google up, “multimedia design firm,” or “all your design needs,” and you’ll know what I’m talking about.
Disclaimer: As Seth Godin says, the ideal is to capture the widest market as possible. However, starting out, that’s pretty much impossible as all the big players will eat you up. So the solution here is to focus and saturate your relatively small niche market with your expertise until it reaches the point of explosion where expanding is the only way to go. Milton Glaser, Sagmeister Inc, Neville Brody and all the other greats have reached this point.
one